Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Balance?

The little girl in the video seems to have achieved more balance than I think I do in my own life. Balance is such an issue. The little girl seems to have it figured out pretty well. Gerty, Ellen, and I, well not so much. Ellen and Gerty both struggle with pleasing their parental figures and get greatly upset when they mess up or do wrong. I find myself in the same position often.

In the scene where Gerty and Miss Emily are chatting in the church, Gerty shows us how unbalanced she really is. She calls herself ugly and "not good." She struggles with the idea that she can even become good. She tries so hard to be good, but it often back fires. She is very hard on herself, also like Ellen. No child should ever have to wonder if they are loved. Gerty does. This is not balance. There should be a balance between love and discipline in a child's life. Gerty can't seem to find this. She struggles with doing good, and not having hatred in her heart.

I think that if Gerty appeared on the talk show we would see that she is very much so not balanced. As I stated above she has a huge inner struggle. I think Gerty would be most unpleasant on the show. She doesn't respect authority well, and doesn't handle things that she doesn't understand well at all. I'm anxious to learn how Gerty develops as her heart is starting to soften as her relationship with Miss Emily grows. She is starting to see that there is a lot more good in life than she thinks.

5 comments:

  1. I agree that Gerty is definitely unstable and is not balanced but I believe that she will gain it and is on the path to gaining control like Anna has. I think she is struggling in a large way but she will learn to be and to understand that she is good.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I totally agree that Gerty is unstable! I did not think about it like that! Very interesting thought though. Gerty definitely does not have the same kind of control that Anna displays. I think that it would make a very interesting talk show.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with your opinion on Gerty living anunstable life. Without all that background teaching and knowledge and early abuse, it's definitely expected that she would have lots of struggle when trying to change her ways later in life.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree Gerty is totally unbalanced but I thought that she did try very hard to be as balanced as possible. She relieved stress just like Anna did in the video, Gerty just did it in a really loud violent way, screaming! As far as Gerty on the talk show, you are right! It would have probably been one entertaining talk show!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I like that you pointed out Gerty's inner struggle and how she is pretty unstable as a little girl. I imagined Gerty's appearance on the tv show would be just plain awkward, but you have a good point about it being unpleasant. That's a great point!

    ReplyDelete